El Norte Essay

Gregory Navas El Norte debuted in the Telluride Film fiesta in 1983 and presents the challenges and realities of migration and multi paganism. though the films settings ar not uniform with todays scenarios, it is still an important work because it provides and periodical anthology of the migrant issues as well as a background to todays multicultural issues. A study of the film reveals not barely the developments in the perceptions regarding immigration but withal the development of niche cultural groups from the attitude of both original and adoptive societies.Moreover, El Norte apprises that cultural biases exist in various levels of society level in seemingly homogenous adepts and that cultural disambiguation creates kind vulnerabilities. Therefore, the movie can provide valuable insights on how multicultural psychology develops and changes in different settings. In turn, the insights that can be highly-developed can help address the issues faced by the Xuncax family, p articularly by the genus Rosa and Enrique in their quest to find their way and to establish a new life in the fall in States.In all terce parts of the movie, cultural differences remain a dominant issue. Tackled closely with social issues, the films view is that culture is both a ascendant of strength and a bane for the siblings. At the same time, the change in both Rosa and Enriques view of their experience and their prospects chthonicgoes a transfiguration that challenges them to find their place in the social schema. Immigrants or Refugees One of the major(ip) issues that atomic number 18 being explored in the movie is regarding the status of Rosa and Enrique as migrant or refugees.This issue is one that has become an interest in consideration of the political and economic persecution that became prevalent in autocratic and militarists governments in S come out of the closeth America. Many countries, in the interest of controlling the influx of multinational established qu alifications that can be considered as refugees, eligible for sanctuary and those that ar to be considered as migrants. The usual consensus seemed to be that political persecution was to be the keister for refugee status while migrants were associated with economic motivations.Furthermore, the status of immigrants requires judiciality where eligibility is based on an privates productive capacity. In the case of the main characters of the movie, they started out more as refugees. The circumstances that motivated them to leave Guatemala were because of persecution against indios their motivation was clear not economic in nature. Rather, it was because of fear against threats against their life due to their ethnicity. At the same time, one classifies the siblings as refugees because they are not given the excerpt of staying or going back to Guatemala or to seek the protection of their government.However, they are not given this status but does not any fulfil the tenants of bei ng considered as immigrants recognized by the United States. Considering these, Rosa and Enrique are to be considered as immigrants, however it should be noted that their lack of legal status makes such a classification problematic as well. In more contemporary terms, they are to be considered as illegal migrants, incomplete of their own boorish or the one they are currently in. Challenges and ImplicationsIt is intelligible that thither is reluctance to consider them as refugees since such a status, under the international charters, makes them eligible not only for residence in the United States but also makes them eligible for social assistance and placement. In contrast, immigrants are managed by the conditions of their migration or residence programs and there is greater leeway for their jutting when they are proven to be unproductive or detrimental to society. Thus, Rosa and Enrique can only turn to illegal means of entering the country as illustrated by their association with a coyote who smuggles them into the country.Though this bypasses the bureaucratism look ated to gain both refugee and immigrant status, it also has left them vulnerable to aversion since they can not seek legal or judicial preventative if they deal to. Furthermore, since they already entered the country illegally, the shake up burned their bridges in gaining legal recognition in the country. The siblings both offer perspectives on the institutions that migrants acquit to deal with. Rosas perspective is that their journey north has only led them from death to greater poverty and questioning if they have a place anywhere in the world except in death.Enrique reflects the fantasy that he is considered simply a factor of production, a strong develop, gaining no greater value than livestock or equipment. In either case, the siblings show that they see themselves apart from society, excluded by their circumstance and history. Acculturation Though the associates of the siblings are generally limited to their own community of migrants, this is not to suggest that they do not make an effort to become part of the general society. However, their efforts are often deterred by cultural and social preconceptions that box them into their roles as illegal immigrants.At the same time, they were being challenged to adjust to their roles within their win community as many of the racism they faced against their indigenous inheritance in Guatemala persisted. The irony is that they heritage that they are being persecuted form is also the source of the philosophical perspective that give them the will to survive and remain firm the conditions and challenges of their journey north. The siblings peg all of their social interactions from their observations as well as each others perspectives.The issue of turning back from ones cultural heritage is an underlying theme of the story since from the precise beginning, perceived cultural inferiorities were the crux of the challeng es faced by Rosa and Enriques family. Thus, within the socially excluded community they are categorized in by mainstream society they remain outsiders. It is then apparent from the observations and interactions of the siblings that their acculturation is always from and externalists perspective. Therefore, as Rosa and Enrique tried to adjust to their circumstance, there seems to be an acceptation that they will neither be able to be part of their community. immigration Policies and El Norte The conjecture that the illegal immigrant trade is one that is protected and even encouraged is a perspective that is presented in the story. Illegal immigrants provide brazen-faced ram, a blanket against social security requirements and a labor total for jobs that are unwanted jobs. At the same time, immigrants are able to have livelihoods that allow them to subsist as they try to gain the tenure they need to apply for legitimacy. However, there is credence to Enriques sentiment that such a scenario has left them in a continued disadvantage.He points out that their blank space has left them not only economically, socially or politically single out but also has made him question his worth as an individual and cultural heritage. The United States remains to be the preferred country for migration and there is still a great need for migrants particularly to sustain labor forces in jobs that are considered blue-collar in nature, However, the reality is that the country is already facing high unemployment among its citizens and there is a slow down of the economy.Thus, the need to control migration is also justified, if not necessary. At the same time, the persistence of ethnicity or culture as a bias still persists despite the plaque of political institutions that are to protect social diversity. The reality is that the issue is not so much regarding migration but the lack of viable opportunities and the inequitable statistical distribution of wealth within nations and i nternationally.